Ambassador of Books ~ Book Club Madam ~ Blogger Gal
Showing posts with label guest book review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label guest book review. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Guest Review: Just Don't Call Me Ma'am

Please welcome today's guest reviewer, my friend and book club buddy, Melissa.  She is originally from Tennessee but lives in Maryland for now.  When I received a copy of this particular book I knew I had to pass it along to her to read - it seemed to be the perfect fit! I hope you enjoy her review!


by Anna Mitchael
248 pages


Just Don't Call Me Ma'am: How I Ditched the South, Forgot My Manners, and Managed to Survive My Twenties with (Most of) My Dignity Still IntactAs I plan the first of many of my summer adventures into New York City, this Southern girl feels the push and pull between my roots and the fabulousness of living close to everything! So Anna Mitchael's journey of self-discovery really hit home with me. The entire title speaks for itself - Just Don't Call Me Ma'am: How I Ditched the South, Forgot My Manners, and Managed to Survive My Twenties with (Most of) My Dignity Still Intact.

Her story begins in 2nd person, which was brilliant. She walked you through the awful break-up discussion we've all had. The memoir is then organized by what Mitchael will answer to. For example, each chapter is entitled, "Call Me a Foodie" or "Call Me a Partner in Cohabitation Crime." Each chapter meanders (and if I'm being honest, wanders a bit) through the mistakes of her twenties and what in her Southern roots caused these problems. Unlike a lot of chick lit, Mitchael doesn't whine about her current pickle; instead, her pithy writing speaks for itself. Exhibit A: "Other people had the kinds of grandmas who baked cookies with you, and grandpas who sat you in their laps  and told inspirational stories about the Great Depression. My grandpa encouraged my success with a plastic Minnie Mouse poolstick" (19). From this one sentence you can feel her mixed emotions about her childhood without a paragraph full of "Why didn't my family blah, blah, blah?"

Exhibit B: She discusses the universal loathing of being a bridesmaid. But in lieu of whining, she says, "Because really, is there anything better than spending a Saturday night in the middle of someone else's family drama? Raising a glass to the happy couple, the stoned younger brother of the bride, the overbearing mother of the groom - it's like being a fly on the wall of someone else's Thanksgiving Day pain" (51).

While the topics may be common chick lit territory, her spin is unique and funny!
In the end, Mitchael does come to a similar "happy to be myself" kind of resolution that most chick lit follows to the letter, but she is a warm, funny writer. And everyone can relate to the simultaneous love/hate relationship with wherever you're from. It's a fun summer read!

Friday, October 23, 2009

My Gram Reads WWII Books

I've written before about my Gram and Grandpa and how they met during WWII. I've never told you the whole story nor will I today (hopefully I'll get around to it one day - it's a great one!), but I do want to tell you a few things because they are related to some books Gram has read recently.

Eileen (aka Gram) was 16 years old in 1940. She lived in Coventry, England with her parents, 2 sisters, and 1 brother. This was the year that Germany began regularly bombing Coventry. All my life Gram has told me stories about her father loading the family up into their car at night and driving them out to the middle of the fields outside town, and how they'd spend the night sleeping in the car to escape the bombings. She's told me about her older brother, Jimmy, and how he was a fire watcher who had to stay on the rooftops in town during bombing runs to warn of fires that might spread through the town, and how the rest of the family would worry about him every night. She's also told me about hiding under metal staircases during air raids.

I recently asked her if she ever hid in the bomb shelters and she said no. Her father said they were too dirty and he preferred to take the family into the fields in the fresh air. Gram said the bomb shelters were used by drunks as a place to have sex, and that you could smell the urine from outside - she never went into one.

A few years later she got a job doing "war work" in a factory in Coventry. The factory was on Spawn Street and Coventry Road. Her job was to make needles and some little brass things, and she was paid by the gross. She still has one of those little brass things somewhere in her house. Her boss's name was Mr. Bolton and he was a very nice man, nice to all the girls who worked in the factory. Whenever there was an afternoon air raid he'd tell the girls to go home and they'd all run as quick as they could. Gram would run down Spawn Street and make a left onto Hollyhead Road. Her house was on that street, less than a mile from the factory. One day she came to work to find that the factory had been bombed during the night and the roof was gone. They were still able to work that day, but when they came to work the next day, the entire factory was gone.

One night, after sleeping in the fields, Gram's family came home to find an unexploded bomb sitting in the middle of their road. It had a fin that was sticking up into the air. Everyone was excited and touching it. Gram says she realizes now that they were all crazy, that it could have exploded at any moment, but no one seemed to realize that then.


When I heard about the book COVENTRY by Helen Humphreys I knew I had to read it, if only to get a better idea of what Gram went through. After I commented on her review, Amanda offered to send me her copy of the book so I could share it with Gram on her next visit. Aren't bloggers wonderful?

Well, Gram's visit finally came around but things haven't gone as planned. She and my Grandpa were supposed to stay in Maryland for a month and return to Florida in September. Unfortunately, while she was here Gram was diagnosed with Stage 3 Lymphoma and is currently undergoing chemotherapy. She's really struggling with it, and it is, of course, difficult for the rest of the family as well. This woman who was bowling three times a week in August now can hardly sit up at the table for more than a few minutes. But she's been reading when she can, and she was very excited when I brought over COVENTRY for her to try.

I can give no better endorsement to the book than to say that according to Gram, Humphreys got everything right. She would have loved to see her street, Hollyhead Road, mentioned but otherwise she loved this book. In fact, Gram enjoyed the book so much that she gave it to her younger sister when she came to visit; Aunt Hilda read it in 2 days and loved it as well. So if you want to know what it was really like to live in Coventry during World War II, you definitely need to read this book - I'm doing that right now.

~~~~~~~~~~

I also brought Gram my copy of THE GUERNSEY LITERARY AND POTATO PEEL PIE SOCIETY. She breezed through that book in just a few days (before starting COVENTRY) and loved it as well. She absolutely loved the character of Elizabeth. Gram doesn't remember hearing anything about Guernsey back during the war; like me, she was completely surprised that the German's occupied the island. She was, however, very familiar with the fact that children were sent away from their families and into the countryside to keep them safe. It didn't happen in her family but she knew that it was happening in others. Gram highly recommends this book as well. Her sister Hilda was planning to get it from the library when she went back home after her visit with Gram.

The book currently on Gram's shelf is THE MIRACLE OF THE NORTH PLATTE CANTEEN. I've had this book for quite a while and have been meaning to read it. As with COVENTRY, Gram is beating me to it. I'll let you know what she thinks about this WWII book as soon as she finishes.

Thursday, October 15, 2009

Sunnyside Blues + Giveaway

Guest Review:
Sunnyside Blues
by Mary Carter
326 pages

A while back I received a book for review and my book club pal Nancy asked to read it. She is not a blogger so I can't tell you to go visit her site, but I can show you a picture of my book club with Nancy in it:

Nancy is back row, center, in purple - I'm in front in red

I hope you enjoy Nancy's review:
I am a member of the Storie delle Sorelle book club, a wife, mother of two young adult children, crafter, cook, gardener, and friend. I had the pleasure of reading Mary Carter's novel SUNNYSIDE BLUES. One will not be disappointed. The author focuses on Andes, a snake handler from West Virginia who is running from her past, and Chase, the 10-year-old son of Jay, the drunken owner of a houseboat in Seattle. There are many twists and turns that begin when Andes wants to rent Jay's houseboat. Andes soon finds herself responsible for Chase. They embark on a journey through which they find a sense of family, love, and discover their true selves.
Nancy really enjoyed this book, as she told me in several different emails. And thanks to author Mary Carter, you can enjoy it too!



Giveaway


For a chance to win a copy of SUNNYSIDE BLUES simply leave a comment below telling me why you want to read this book. Per the author, this contest is open to US residents only. I will announce the winner on 10/23.

Note: If your email address is not easily to access through your blog or profile, please be sure to leave it in your comment.



Other Reviews


For more opinions on this book check out these reviews:
Book Chatter and Other Stuff
Should Be Reading
Did I miss yours?

Sunday, March 1, 2009

Book Review Carnival

Welcome to the 12th Book Review Blog Carnival!

Thank you to everyone who submitted a review for this event - the response was overwhelming and I have so many great reviews to share with you all. To make things easy to peruse (since this is a very long list) I've split the list into genre groups then alphabetized the reviews in each group by title. Let me know if that works well for you or not.

For those who are new to Carnivals, please don't be in shock over the length of this post. Simply browse the titles then click the links to visit those reviews that catch your eye. You can stick to your favorite genre or explore others that are new to you. Carnivals are all about discovering new books and having fun doing it.

More info on the Book Review Carnival can be found at the BRC blog: bookcarnival.wordpress.com.

And now, the reviews!


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

*** Children's/Juvenile Books ***

  • ANIMAL TRACKS & SIGNS, by Jinny Johnson - Urban Science Adventures! says " is perfect for animal lovers and junior naturalists of all ages.... I recommend taking it along with you on your outdoor adventures..." What kid wouldn't enjoy exploring with this?!

  • HATTIE BIG SKY, by Kirby Lawson - Hope is the Word loved this book. She says "In addition to being a Newberry Honor book for 2007, this novel is also based on the author's own family history; her great grandmother was the original Hattie who struck out on her own on the Montana prairie as a sixteen year old. Knowing that such stories actually took place made this novel all the richer for me." This was never a book that I wanted to read, but I'm a sucker for books based on someones real-life family history so I'll definitely have to check this one out.

  • SAVVY, by Ingrid Law - Children's Book Reviews and Then Some says "I discovered that the words inside the book are just as dazzlingly, swirlingly, colorfully beautiful as the cover art. [...] You will find yourself totally absorbed by the wet, humid, crackling world that Ingrid Law creates in this book." If you've seen the cover of SAVVY you'll know what an amazing description that really is.

  • SEVEN MILES TO FREEDOM: THE ROBERT SMALLS STORY, by Janet Halfman - Book Dads says this book "is the astonishing true story of Robert Smalls, an African-American who became one of the greatest heroes of the American Civil War." He goes on to say that the "story of Robert Smalls' life ... is not only a story about slavery ... it's a story about how fatherhood can make all of us better men...." It is amazing the lessons we can find in history and in children's books, is it not?
  • THE ARK, THE REED, AND THE FIRE CLOUD, by Jenny Cote - Kiddo and I reviewed this 400+ page book about the animals making their way to Noah's ark.
*** Fiction ***
  • Australian fiction in general - Becoming a Fiction Writer gives brief reviews of four books and says "I thought I'd share some of these recent great reads with you - both for my Aussie readers who have probably heard about these books and those of you in other far flung corners who might enjoy hearing what Australia has to offer."
  • CHANGE OF HEART, by Jodi Picoult - I reviewed this book and I explained in detail all the things that I couldn't stand about it.

  • FUP, by Jim Dodge - The Truth About Lies says that this very short book "is a remarkably laid back little book in that it feels neither rushed nor so crammed full of details there's no room for the story." But the part I found interesting is when he says "Remember The Sixth Sense, The Crying Game, and the original Planet of the Apes? In each there was a major reveleation that you really didn't want to know about before you saw the film and yet were desperate to share afterwards. Fup is like that." Hmm, now I'm really intrigued.

  • LIFE OF PI, by Yann Martel - My Two Blessings says this book "is an oddly fascinating tale that keeps you reading, wandering what is going to happen next." I couldn't agree more.

  • THE BOOK OF NIGHT WOMEN, by Marlon James - Linus's Blanket says "when I began reading Lilith's story I was immediately drawn in and could not put it down. It's a pretty substantial book, yet I was through with it in just a few short days." Those are the best kind of books, ones where you're not worried about the page count because you're so into the story.

  • THE FUGITIVE PIGEON, by Donald E. Westlake - Karen't List of Books says "I do not konw whether Westlake was a fan of P.G. Wodehouse but there is much about thie book that reminds me of Wodehouse. Funny, well paced, with well drawn characters, it is indeed a 'comedy of perils.'" I love Wodehouse so that's a ringing endorsement in my opinion.

  • THE HUNGER GAMES, by Suzanne Collins - Bart's Bookshelf says "The premise initially seems to be a mix of Battle Royale, Lord of the Flies and Big Brother, and yes it is a mix of those things, but is has it's own very clear identity as well. [...] If this book doesn't make my top books of the year list, then I have some bloody good books to read between now and December." I have yet to read a negative review of this book an any blog.
  • WIDEACRE, by Philippa Gregory - Books I Done Read says that according to her rating system this book gets "Six caterpillars for style, but nine for DRAMA! So seven-and-a-half." If you've never read her reviews before you must go check this one out. This gal is hysterical!
*** Mysteries & Thrillers ***

  • A RULE AGAINST MURDER, by Louise Penny - My Random Acts of Reading says "Louise Penny's writing is wonderfully musical, and she has a real gift for keeping the reader hurrying along, while still wanting to savor the words."

  • IN THE WOODS, by Tana French - My Random Acts of Reading says that what "I didn't know was how I would carry this book everywhere and sneak in pages in between tasks, at stoplights, and when I couldn't sleep in the night. It was that absorbing." I've heard that same sentiment echoed on other blogs too!

  • O JERUSALEM, by Laurie R. King - Books and Movies says "In The Beekeeper's Apprentice, Mary Russell and Sherlock Holmes have to lay low for a while.... They accept an assignment from Holmes' brother Mycroft, which sends them to Palestine. [This book] gives us that venture in detail." This one is already on my list to read in March - I can't wait to read it!

  • several Hercule Poirot stories, by Agatha Christie - Mysteries in Paradise gives a unique perspective on several of these stories by "interviewing" Poirot himself. What fun!
  • THE LOW ROAD, by Chris Womersley - Mysteries in Paradise says "Wild, a doctor de-registered because of his morphine addiction, cast out by his wife, and on the run from the law, checks into a dingy motel on the fringe of the city." Aah, a great start to the story!

  • THE MYSTERY OF THE BLUE TRAIN, by Agatha Christie - Mysteries in Paradise says "There are plenty of red herrings, a further fleshing out of the character of Poirot as a person that young women find attractive, and puzzles to keep the brain engaged." Ah, Poirot, you gotta love him.



  • THE SKY TOOK HIM, by Donis Casey - My Random Acts of Reading says this book "is the fourth book in Donis Casey's historical mystery series" set in early 20th century Oklahoma.
  • THE THREE MISTAKES OF MY LIFE, by Cheten Bhagat - Book Reviews says this book is almost identical to the author's other books. He goes on to say "If I don't compare this novel with [his] earlier works. Then I am really impressed with this book. It has friendship, love, business, cricket, religion, riots, and ya happy ending, everything a bollywood movie demands."

  • THE UNEARTHED, by Brian O'Rourke - About this paranormal thriller Books Books and More Books says "I'd really hate to post any spoilers ... but let me tell you, this book is spectacularly written."
*** Sci-Fi & Fantasy ***

  • ANIMAL FARM, by George Orwell - Ms. Smarty Pants Know It All says "
    Even though Orwell was commenting specifically on socialism-communisim within the Soviet Union and on their influences on the West, my modern mindset allows me to apply the events of the book to a number of contemporary issues" which she goes on to do.

  • HOPE'S FOLLY, by Linnea Sinclair - Book Calendar says "This book is what Star Trek might be if it included hot sex, and more violent political intrigue. Including this adds spice where most space operas don't have it. This is the major reason I like her stories so much." Woohoo! Sounds like fun.

  • LOOK TO WINDWARD, by Iain M. Banks - True Science Fiction says "add in some awesome AIs, a variety of interesting alien species and world settings, and a load of metaphysics (Sublimed beings - they sound a lot like ascended beings from Stargate, but without all the rules), and you have the makings of a killer sci fi story." Unfortunately True Science Fiction goes on to say that the author "isn't jumping to the top of my book pile."

  • OLD MAN'S WAR, by John Scalzi - Things Mean A Lot says it "is a funny and action-filled military sci-fi story. But it’s really just as funny as it is serious and sad. It's about fighting, yes, but doesn’t glorify war. Nor does it do the opposite ..." I've been hearing lots about this book lately, and it has all been good.

  • THE ABRAXAS, by Cinsearae Santiago - Books Books and More Books says this is "more interesting than just a typical vampire story ... The plot ... kept getting thicker and thicker, when you thought they were through with the fighting - you turned the page and you were wrong!"

  • THE AMULET OF SAMARKAND, by Jonathan Stroud - Gabriel Gadfly says that this young adult book is "action-packed book, and one that will keep you on the edge of your seat. [...] The ending is satisfying but leaves plenty of loose ends unresolved. As it is, I'm dying to read the second book in the trilogy."
*** Poetry ***

*** Memoir ***

  • HONEYMOON IN TEHRAN, by Azadeh Moaveni - The 3 R's: Reading, 'Riting, and Randomness says "not long after I began reading Honeymoon in Tehran, I ran across a copy of Azadeh Moaveni's earlier memoir, Lipstick Jihad, in a bookstore, and bought it with no hesitation - I already knew I was going to want more of her story."

  • ROAD TO QUOZ: AN AMERICAN MOSEY, by William Least Heat Moon - I'll Never Forget the Day I Read the Book calls this "the millennial era's answer to Charles Kuralt." He goes to add "Suffice it to say that he likes odd and interesting stuff, especially if it's old. He is able to tease a story out of each discovery." Plus there is some sort of fascination with the letter Q ...
*** Non-Fiction ***
  • ACCELERATED DISTANCE LEARNING, by Brad Voeller - Debt Free College says this is "is an excellent road map, helping you to your degree."
  • AFRICAN DIARIES: SKETCHES & OBSERVATIONS, by David G. Derrick, Jr. - Grrl Scientist says "This slim paperback is an unusual travel diary because it is comprised of more than 140 of hand-drawn pictures of people and animals, along with accompanying photographs and hand0written notes, all created while the author was traveling through Kenya, Africa. ... Even though this is a paperback, it is printed on heavy paper and the images are of high enough quality that you can actually see the grain of the paper upon which the sketches and paintings were originally created." She posts samples of the artwork in her review as well.
  • BEYOND HEAVING BOSOMS: THE SMART BITCHES GUIDE TO ROMANCE NOVELS, by Sarah Wendell and Candy Tan - Love, Romance, Passion says that this book is "the ultimate end all be all guide for romances. You won’t be able to talk about romance again without using this book because they’ve covered it all: lead types, plot tropes, standard clichés, wtf moments, sex, and HEAs." And what's more, this guide "will definitely bring tears of laughter to your eyes as well as enlighten readers to why women love to read romances." After that review I really want to read this book ... and I'm not even romance reader! (And now I'm curious as to what an HEA is - can anybody help?)

  • EXTRAORDINARY KNOWING, by Elizabeth Lloyd Mayer - Science on Tap says "This is a book about ... knowing things without understanding how we know them. ... [The author collected] stories/anecdotes from her medical colleagues of odd, inexplicable experiences of 'knowing' things at a distance or ahead of time." The book also covers the "strange history of paranormal research." Even though I'm not into paranormal anything, I found this review fascinating and will definitely consider reading this book.

  • GORGEOUSLY GREEN: 8 SIMPLE STEPS TO AN EARTH-FRIENDLY LIFE, by Sophie Uliano - Less is More says "If you are looking for ways to become greener, the book is worth looking throuh, however think of the products it suggests as future alternatives rather than immediate needs."

  • HUNGER: AN UNNATURAL HISTORY, by Sharman Apt Russell - Rebecca Reads says the author "details what it means, physiologically, to be hungry. Then she goes beyond the science of hunger and into social aspects by reviewing the history of how we learned to help starving people recover and the various current worldwide issues surrounding hunger." This book sounds horrifying. Fascinating, but horrifying.

  • MARTHA STEWART'S COOKIES, cookbook - Less is More says "I haven't baked anything out of this book yet but if it's half as good as EVERDAY FOOD: GREAT FOOD FAST then it'll be a hit." Is it odd that a cookbook follows a book on hunger when I alphabetized this list?

  • PRAIRIE SPRING: JOURNEY INTO THE HEART OF A SEASON, by Peter Dunne - The Birder's Library says the author "chronicles a spring that he and his wife spent on America's grasslands. ... Birds, of course, figure prominently into the account ... however ... it does not focus exclusively on birds. It encompasses the entire ecology, and even history, of the American prairie." An amazing place, to be sure, and one I've always wanted to visit.

  • THE EMPEROR'S EMBRACE: REFLECTIONS ON ANIMAL FAMILIES AND FATHERHOOD, by Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson - Book Dads says "is quite simply the seminal and definitive guide to animal fatherhood. ... [It] puts the lie to the idea that mothers are inherently more suited to care for children than fathers due to some kind of biological destiny, and will make any man proud to count himself part of a fraternity of fatherhood that extends not only to other humans but to our animals cousins as well." This book sounds fascinating to me. It may end up on my TBR list soon.

  • THE LOST CITY OF Z: A TALE OF DEADLY OBSESSION IN THE AMAZON, by David Grann - At Home With Books says it "is such a riveting story, that it is easy at first to mistake this nonfiction book for a novel. In the preface you are thrust right into the action as the author reveals that he is lost in the Amazon, giving you a taste of what is to come." This reminds me of that Discovery Channel Show "I Shouldn't Be Alive" ... the same show that almost gives me nightmares but that I continue watching anyway.

  • THE SCIENCE OF PARENTING, by Margot Sunderland - Babylicious says "For any person who truly desires to raise their child in a manner that will offer that child the best skills for happiness, emotional well-being and success in life, this is the book for you."
  • SOUIXSIE AND THE BANSHEES: THE AUTHORISED BIOGRAPHY, by Shirley Manson - Quillotine says "if perhaps you prefer salacious rumour peppered with hideous cliches of the rock and roll trade please leave this book on the shelf. if so stay at home. this is one for the scholars of rock. open your moleskin. reach for your quill. take notes."
*** Business & Finance ***
  • BLUE OCEAN STRATEGY, by W. Chan Kim and Renee Mouborgne - Smarter Wallet says this book shows "an approach designed to tackle a market where you have absolutely no competition, where you can become a pioneer in the industry."

  • CAREER RENEGADE: HOW TO MAKE A GREAT LIVING DOING WHAT YOU LOVE, by Jonathan Fields - Bargaineering says "The introduction is eleven pages. The next time you're in a bookstore, look for the book and read those eleven pages. ... It explains exactly what the book is about, without and salesmanship or BS. ... After you're done reading the introduction you will know whether or not this book is for you."

  • MADE TO STICK, by Chip & Dan Heath - Learn This says "while the book might seem from the topic to fit only the presenting, marketing or sales type of roles and personalities, it is certainly not limited to those groups of people. It is an entertaining book that will enable anyone to share their ideas more effectively."

  • PLUNDER: INVESTIGATING OUR ECONOMIC CALAMITY AND THE SUBPRIME SCANDAL, by Danny Schechter - Blog Business World says if you read this book "you will gain a greater understanding of the origins of the subprime meltdown that led to the current finanical crisis. This economic knowledge could very well save your bank account, your investments, and your home." Very strong words, and a ringing endorsement of this book.

  • POOR CHARLIE'S ALMANAC, by Peter D. Kaufman - GeekMBA360 says "I think it is one of the greatest investment books of our time."

  • THE FRUGAL MILLIONAIRES, by Jeff Lehman - Bargaineering says "What I expected to find were some tips that would help me save tens or hundreds of dollars ... which would be well worth my time to read!" Did the book live up to those expectations? Read the review to find out.

  • WORDPRESS FOR BUSINESS BLOGGING, by Paul Thewlis - Search for Blogging says "Whether you already have a blog, or are still in the planning stages, this book can show you how to use WordPress to create a highly successful blog for your business."
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

If you made it all the way through the list, congratulations! I hope you found something to interest you in the myriad titles above. Post a comment and let me know if any of the books made it on to your TBR list. You tell me yours and I'll tell you mine ...

    Wednesday, February 25, 2009

    Mom & Son Book Club #10: The Ark, the Reed, and the Fire Cloud

    The Ark, the Reed, & the Fire Cloud
    by Jenny Cote
    448 pages
    (review by kiddo)

    I received this book from the publisher and have really enjoyed reading it to kiddo. I'll let kiddo do his review first (with my comments in italics, as usual) and post mine later in the day(update: here's the link to mine). Kiddo's review comes with a spoiler warning though - he gives lots of things away in his answers.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    1. Did you like this book? I liked it except for two parts. Why did you like it? Because it had lots of exciting parts and lots of "what's gonna happen next?! what's gonna happen next?!" - those kind of parts. Ah, suspense - its like a drug to us book addicts!

    2. What was your favorite part? All of it except for two parts. Any thing specific? Oh yeah! When Max was fighting the snake and when the four animals got eternal life.

    3. What was your least favorite part? When they had to leave Gillamon and when we found out that Charlie was bad.

    4. What did you think of the illustrations? The pictures were ok. The frog singing was not so good but the one with Henriette is good. I'd like the pictures better if they had color. I was going to - if you say ok - I was going to color in some of the pictures. No kiddo, I'm sorry, you can't color in books. I'm such a mean mom, I know. Do you think the book needed more pictures or did you do ok with imagining things? I did ok imagining but most of the animals, since I didn't know what they looked like, it was hard to imagine them. Actually, I think kiddo did really well with this. Often when I was reading and I thought things might be a bit confusing, I'd tell him to close his eyes and imagine what was happening. I'd read one sentence at a time then ask it he could "see" it. Sometimes he could and other times he needed some additional explanations. But always, when he opened his eyes, I could see the excitement, the light that went off - he "saw" it happening in his head. It was so cool to watch!

    5. Would you recommend this book to your friends? YES. As long as they read it quickly. Why? Because if they didn't read it quickly they might forget what happens or they might lose the book. Did we read it quickly? Kind of, except for parts. We started it then stopped then started another book then came back to it. Um, yeah, kiddo's sense of time is a bit off here. We started this book way back in October and we finally finished it earlier this week. But I will say that the story did not drag nor did we put it aside because we tired of it. It took so long simply because we read only 1 or 2 chapters every couple days. And we only picked up another book because kiddo got WIZARDOLOGY for his birthday and really wanted to read it. And for the record, kiddo didn't forget anything that happened in this book..

    6. Is there anything else you'd like to say about this book? These are the animals I liked: Max, Gillamon, Kate, Al, Liz, Jaques, Georgio, and Don Pedro. And these are the people I liked Noah, Shem, Japeth (kind of) and Ham (kind of), and out of the girls, Noah's wife and Shem's wife. Japeth's wife and Ham's wife were ok. What did you think about the author adding to the story in the Bible? I liked that. Do you think it's ok to add to the Bible story when the Bible story doesn't give you the details? YES. In fact, I might add something to it. What would you add? Well, I'd like to have the story of Jesus when he died on the cross with Max and Liz and Kate and Al and Gillamon and God speaking would be in it as well.
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    Kiddo also wanted to send an email to the author, Jenny Cote. He thinks that since I get signed books from authors and that some authors comment on my blog, I can talk to any author I want whenever I want. I wish! But anyway, here's kiddo's message to Ms. Cote: The book was a very nice book. I would love to read it again and get the new book that you are writing, The Dreamer, The Schemer and The Robe. I'm happy to help you make more stories when you are ready.
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    I hope you'll come back later today for my review. There are lots of things I'd like to discuss about this book!

    Thursday, January 15, 2009

    The Best Friend I Ever Had (a guest review)

    Please welcome my guest reviewer for today, Erika Robuck. I met Erika a few months ago at the Maryland Writers Association meeting when I spoke about book blogging.

    Erika is a writer and amateur historian. She writes historical fiction, and is publishing her novel, Receive Me Falling, in early 2009. [I'm REALLY looking forward to reading it!] When she's not doing research or writing, she spends her time with her family in Maryland and North Carolina . You can check out her book at www.erikarobuck.com, and her blog at www.erikarobuck.wordpress.com.

    She is also a huge fan of Hemingway, so when I received this book for review I KNEW she'd be the perfect person to read it.


    The Best Friend I Ever Had: Revelations About
    Ernest Hemingway From Those Who Knew Him
    by David Nuffer
    167 pages

    David Nuffer’s book, The Best Friend I Ever Had, is a compilation of the author’s correspondence and interviews with people who knew Ernest Hemingway. It is 167 pages so it is a quick read, and it is full of photos, copies of letters, and various other artifacts supporting the author’s work.

    Nuffer is not an academic, and both directly and indirectly expresses his negative opinion of Hemingway academics. It seems he has adopted the wary and skeptical view toward Hemingway scholars that the people who knew Hemingway did. This is not a scholarly work, and it is openly biased in its opinion of Ernest Hemingway. Though some previously unpublished letters from the Mayo Clinic and personal anecdotes from Hemingway’s son, Patrick, and third wife, Mary, might interest the true Hemingway scholar, the target audience for the book would be limited to serious fans of Hemingway.

    The book was interesting and readable. Apart from a few formatting errors, it was clear in its presentation. The best parts of it came from the people who knew Hemingway, firsthand. Their amusing anecdotes and loyalty to the author were well portrayed and touching.

    What the book lacked, however, was organization. It felt very much like a list David Nuffer typed up of all the Hemingway “stuff” he knew. At the end of each section, he did truly list points he wanted to convey, but didn’t embed within the prose. It felt as if I were reading notes for a speech. Some of the items in his list needed elaboration, but the way they were presented left the reader feeling like she was on the outside of an inside conversation.

    I can identify with Nuffer’s love of Hemingway and his passion to “right” the reputation of him. I think that if Nuffer had organized the text chronologically, and had made more of an attempt to turn his findings into fluent prose it would appeal to a wider audience. As it is, only the true Hemingway lover would find it of interest.


    Thanks Erika for this review. I can't believe that you only had this book for two days - I think that's the quickest read and review I've ever seen!
    Blog Widget by LinkWithin